Author: Kevin Crossman

Posted on

Mai Tai for Two at Pagan Idol

Was pleased to see that Pagan Idol was fairly busy on Wednesday night, though the venue’s reputation for having the highest backpack to customer ratio seems to still be intact. There were several groups having a great time and while there were ebbs and flows there were a steady stream of customers ordering at the bar.

We started with the Mai Tai that is made with Kō Hana Kea and Appleton Signature, which resulted in a bright flavor that leaned a little in the orange direction. If you’re a fan of Hawaiian rums or any lighter sugar cane spirits then this Mai Tai is a great option. Nathan and I both can be picky but we agreed this was really good Mai Tai.

Nathan didn’t want the night to end just yet and ordered another round including an amazing Daiquiri made with Rum Fire (supposedly “just a splash” but clearly more than that). It had been a while since I’d been in the back room at Pagan and forgot how many tikis are in this section, including two big ones that are still impressive. I didn’t love the Reggae-heavy music playlist, but overall this was a great visit and nice to see Pagan still doing well with the tiki thing in the Financial District.

Posted on

Great Appleton 17 Mai Tai at Kona Street Market

Buckle in for a roller coaster of an experience and note the unique set of circumstances.

I was in the City for a work event and met up with local raconteur Nathan Robinson for drinks at Kona’s Street Market downtown. After enjoying a Kona original called the Banana Stand we had a good rapport with bartender Jason and it wasn’t too busy, so I asked if he could make a 1944 Trader Vic’s Mai Tai using the Appleton 17 Legend rum that newly appeared on their top shelf after the previous bottle was drained a couple months ago.

Note that Kona is still selling this at the ridiculous price of $30 for a neat pour and only a few bucks more in Mai Tai format, making this an absolute bargain.

Jason made sure to check that we didn’t want the dark rum float that normally comes with their Mai Tai and measured everything carefully. But the initial taste was anything but legendary due to what can only be characterized as very bad lime juice. Nathan took a little swig, confirming to us that “the lime is off”. Jason offered to remake it and I him he didn’t have to but after consulting with another member of the team I saw him juicing a fresh lime and preparing another version of the cocktail.

Does the Legend still make a fabulous Mai Tai? Yes, it still does! That second Mai Tai was just how I remember it, a fantastic flavorful rum that is so present in the drink with an extraordinarily long finish so you can savor every sip.

We want to highlight the circumstances of a not-so-busy bar, ongoing conversation with the staff, and the obvious industry experience that Nathan’s questions and comments with the bartender demonstrated. Your mileage would vary if it was slammed or if you roll in to mansplain your way into ordering this off-menu cocktail. A really fantastic experience overall, thanks to Jason and the Kona team.

I left a very big tip.

Banana Stand
Posted on

Alice in Wonderland Pop-Up at The Fat Pigeon Livermore

We’ve visited The Fat Pigeon during the holidays for the Miracle pop-up and decided to visit again for their spring-inspired Alice in Wonderland theme. The decor is nicely set up with some references to characters on the walls, though this is mostly based on the novel and not any movie franchises. Occasional smoke effects and bubbles were a plus to reinforce the theme. Music seems to be off theme, but nicely upbeat and jazzy during our Sunday afternoon visit.

There are a variety of themed cocktails with a diversity of spirits, though many of the items contain spicy/chili elements that I avoided. I would rate these cocktails as pretty good and found that they weren’t too boozy, so possibly a pro or a con. I enjoyed the Bandersnatch & Brandy, a fruity Manhattan riff that had rich mouthfeel. Mrs. Mai Tai seemed to like her cocktails including the King of Hearts with a smoke bubble and some nice orange flavors. There are also a couple of non-alcoholic options including the refreshing “tea-ki” inspired Golden Road to Nowhere that had a great presentation as well.

Our service was super prompt and the $25 grazing board with cheese, fruit, and meats was a pretty good value and a hit with our party.

Posted on

Dr. Funk Rum Asylum Level II: Deleri-rum

Popped into Dr. Funk to drink some rum from the Rum Asylum Level II list, a curated list of 60+ rums from the doctor’s collection.

Mrs Mai Tai is still working level I and she had a Wray & Nephew Overproof rum as a Daiquiri, so I did a little compare and contrast by having The Funk has a daiquiri, a similar unaged Jamaican rum that is a little less boozy (“only 100 proof”) and quite lovely in that format.

Then I tried a delicious AK Zanj 10 year rum from Haiti, made from sugar cane juice. Very approachable and full flavored.

Posted on

Island Glider at Trader Vic’s

Had a nice visit to the bar at Trader Vic’s Emeryville on the way to pick up Mrs. Mai Tai at the airport, where coincidentally my exploration of the vast cocktail menu led me to a new drink called the Island Glider. This is a Paper Plane variant developed by Mika who was actually my bartender for the evening.

The Island Glider features dark rum, Aperol, and Pineapple Amaro and is served up. This is a dry leaning but still flavorful cocktail and a good option for those looking for spirit-forward options, though the use of the Trader Vic’s Dark Rum means that the rum doesn’t quite hold up to the other ingredients as much as you’d want. I appreciate what Mika was trying to do here, and the constraints to use Trader Vic’s branded rums, but this is a case where a bolder rum really would have benefitted this cocktail. The garnish includes nods to hang gliders and is a really nice touch.

Later, Mika demonstrated how the Vic’s bartenders keep up with all those Mai Tai orders by building eleven Mai Tais at one time and keeping them on hand for orders so that all they need to do is add ice, shake, and garnish.

Posted on

Leisuremann’s Mai Tai Cocktail Mix

When procuring an actual ready to drink cocktail isn’t feasible, there’s a new option to consider when all you have is rum. Leisuremann’s produces a number of cocktail mixes, so when I saw that there’s a Leisuremann’s Mai Tai my interest was piqued. We give thanks to Mai Tai fan Jeff Ross for sending me a packet to try.

Let’s not pretend this isn’t what it is; it is a powdered Mai Tai that makes one drink by adding 2 oz of water, 1 oz of rum, and ice. The packet specifically states to use ½ oz each of a “White Rum” and a “Dark Rum”, which rum aficionados know is a not a precise direction. I used Denizen Light rum and our Ultimate Mai Tai rum blend for the two stated rums, but couldn’t really taste the rum in the completed cocktail so in practice you’ll want to increase the rum to a full two ounces.

Compared to ready to drink Mai Tai cocktails or Mai Tai mixes, you could do far worse than Leisuremann’s Mai Tai mix. In fact, I thought this wasn’t half bad and way better than I expected. There is a bit too much orange in the flavor profile but there is some tangy lime and almond flavor in there as well. But that added Coruba rum float certainly improved the overall character of the cocktail.

Posted on

Myers’s Rum Signature Origin Collection Guyana Blend

Though Myers’s Rum will likely forever be known for the signature Dark Jamaican expression, in the past decades this blending brand did issue bottles featuring rum from different regions. The brand’s current owners, Sazerac, went so far as to issue this Guyana variant a couple years back though to date this seems to be a one and done release. The rum is 41.5% ABV and is a blend of rums from Guyana with no age statement.

I was gifted a bottle of this rare rum from Jason Craig and am so grateful to be able to enjoy this fine expression. Tasting neat, it does strike me as similar to El Dorado 5 which I’ve tried several times and compares very favorably to the 40% Pusser’s 15 yr that I have in my collection. Rich toffee, nut, and banana notes mostly, and not too much oak. The lower ABV means that rum nerds likely won’t flock to it, but this is something you could impress a rum newbie with.

The Guyana Blend really shines in a Mai Tai, providing a ton of rummy flavor that pairs really well with the rest of the ingredients. Even at 83 proof, this rum is not buried in the cocktail, and I really enjoyed this Myers’s rum as a Mai Tai.

There still seem to be some bottles of Myers’s Rum Signature Origin Collection Guyana Blend out there for purchase, usually in the $45-$50 range. This interesting expression is worth seeking out and I hope Sazerac does more of these kind of releases.